Site icon Gutternaut

Underrated DC Comics: The Exclusive Checklist

Yes I am making this the preview for Underrated DC Comics

For over 80 years, DC and all of the comic studios that make it up produce quality stories. But for every issue of Batman, there are series that fall off the radar. Some are lucky enough to get nominations for awards; others get good reception but fall into obscurity after a while. But now these hidden gems get dedication in this Underrated DC Comics checklist.

We will be including old classics that don’t come up until years later such as Batman: Ego. A few imprint titles like Young Animal’s Shade comics decorate this page as well. Characters who make more than a few appearances and series get their own sections.

See here for links to more lists:

Underrated DC Comics: General

Underrated DC Comics: Superman

Superman might be tied together with DC Comics but even the diehard fans miss some great series. Whether they ask hard questions or situations that look at surreal situations, someone will be Super fans.

Underrated DC Comics: Batman

Oh come on Batman, do you have to steal what little spotlight other characters need? Whether it’s the teams you set up, where Bruce Wayne fits in, or series that get overlooked for some reason, you’re always there!

Underrated DC Comics: Gotham

As for the city of Gotham herself, it’s a character that interacts greatly with the residents. Because not everybody in Gotham ties themselves to the Bat family.

The Outsiders

The Outsiders are a team commonly in association with Batman and Black Lightning. They compose mostly of DC’s misfits who often don’t get their own titles or work better in teams. For this list we will be focusing more on the iterations that get less adaptations.

Underrated DC Comics: Aquaman

Aquaman is character whose reputation is between an optimistic joke and a warrior king. His time both in and out of Atlantis demonstrates both the rich lore of the submarine settings of DC and Arthur Curry as a hero.

Underrated DC Comics: Green Lantern

While everybody is likely familiar with Hal Jordan or John Stewart, does anybody really get a good glimpse at the entire Corps? Because the Green Lanterns’ role in DC comics should not be overlooked.

Disclaimer: The below series were written by Gerard Jones who was convicted and served time. All that you need to know is that he got out on good behavior and made sure his victims got restitution.

Underrated DC Comics: Justice League

With the many adventures and iterations of the Justice League, there are plenty that slip under the radar.

Legion of Super-Heroes

The Legion of Super-Heroes are an admittedly underrated DC Comics team full of diverse characters similar to the X-Men. But with their time travel gimmicks, it’s easy to lose track of them all.

Fourth World

The Fourth World is Jack Kirby’s epic that reaches out across time. Introducing readers to Darkseid, Orion, and Mister Miracle, it’s easy to forget the work others put into it.

Kamandi Checklist

Kamandi is what happens when the story of Planet of the Apes meets Jack Kirby. As the only human survivor of civilization, Kamandi must venture out into a hostile world. With a very relatable story focusing on finding a place to belong; Kamandi is the Underrated DC comics gem that stretches throughout time.

OMAC

Before Brother Eye and the OMAC Project’s association with Infinite Crisis, the concepts were an original by Jack Kirby. OMAC is an agent of the Global Peace Agency, an organization in the far future that tries to solve crises without violence. Buddy Blank’s alter-ego is merely their means of countering violence.

Etrigan The Demon Checklist

Another Jack Kirby original, The Demon follows the dual life of Jason Blood and his demonic half Etrigan. Among DC’s earliest occult heroes, the adventures range from the horrific to the surreal. Because who doesn’t find it entertaining in regards to a character who speaks in rhymes?

Martian Manhunter

Martian Manhunter is a character many DC fans recognize as a member of the Justice League. Yet most of the time, he’s just a supporting character. Which is a shame because the adventures of J’onn J’onzz is a post-immigration journey.

The Atom

Whether it’s Ray Palmer or Ryan Choi, the Atom represents an enthusiastic side of science fiction.

Sgt. Rock

Sgt. Rock is DC’s premiere military character appearing in the war stories of WWII.

Enemy Ace

Enemy Ace is where the pulpy pilot scene comes to DC. Surprisingly, it describes a German pilot during WWI and WWII. But don’t worry Hans von Hammer is no Nazi. Possessing a code of chivalry, the Hammer tries to find whatever means to hold onto his sanity. But the horrors of war strike at every other turn.

Unknown Soldier

The Unknown Soldier represents the nameless soldiers fighting in America’s wars. Each subsequent series would explore the military’s relationships with its corpsmen and country.

The Losers

No, not the Vertigo team homaging them, but the original Robert Kanigher creations Jack Kirby made famous.

The Haunted Tank

Just when you thought wars couldn’t get any weirder. Or possibly offensive with how the ghost of an American Confederate figure plays a part, even if it does try to subvert labels while showcasing tank combat.

Deadman

Deadman is about a ghost haunted by his senseless death desperately looking for justice. Each new series becomes as surreal and mentally burdensome on Boston Brand.

Amethyst: Princess Of Gemworld

Amethyst: Princess of Gemworld is one of DC’s earlier attempts at a swords and sorcery series. In comparison to Stalker or Warlord this is a coming-of-age series about a lost princess’s awakening to reclaim her home.

The Question

The Question is a character who barely gets any time in the limelight, despite being the inspiration for Watchmen’s Rohrschach. Maybe that’s because it is a name shared between two characters. Vic Sage is always after the next challenge to his identity. The other Question, Renee Montoya is a Gotham detective who serves as a more hardboiled foil to characters like Batwoman.

Dr. Fate

Doctor Fate is DC’s main face of magic, but other than as a passive force or guide through the supernatural, the character doesn’t appear often. Unless you count the times where the mantle goes through its hosts.

Hawkman

Hawkman is a character whose entire identity can only be complicated, hence his underrated DC comics status. Existing since the Golden Age, he has since gone through several revamps to his origin and character. Once a reincarnating Egyptian Prince, then an alien policeman, Carter Hall has since embraced the absurdity surrounding himself. Because when you can exist in one form or another at the same time, you have to question what makes you unique.

The Spectre

DC’s embodiment of vengeance plays a mesmerizing role in the greater universe, by confronting the nature of morality.

Justice Society of America (JSA)

Before the Justice League is the Justice Society! Featuring the likes of the classic Flash and Doctor Mid-Nite, this team comes and goes throughout history.

Underrated DC Comics Checklist: Phantom Stranger

Phantom Stranger is an odd character to be sure; definitely in underrated DC comics. Nobody knows who he is besides another esoteric like Spectre. Making sporadic appearances in other occult series like Swamp Thing, he often acts as a guide of the supernatural.

Human Target

The Human Target has a cult following thanks in no small part to Peter Milligan, a few TV shows, and guest appearances. When it comes to comics though, nobody knows where to look for them until now.

Vigilante

DC’s moniker of Vigilante depicts the role of a gunslinger in the DC universe.

Adam Strange

If there’s an underrated DC Comics character, the poster boy of Strange Adventures, Adam Strange fits that mold. He makes very few appearances other than as a guest character. At this point, most people probably remember him as either a Booster Gold stand-in or a war criminal. But back in the fifties, the Space Race was the biggest factor for DC to try and capture. When Captain Comet doesn’t quite reach this, Adam Strange combines pulp adventurers with closer-to-reality science fiction. Later depictions show Adam’s struggles to immigrate to his adopted homeworld of Rann.

Underrated DC Comics: Booster Gold Checklist

Booster Gold is a character known for comic relief, where he tries to be taken seriously. Between the funny man antics however comes a genuine sense of humanity on the burdens of time travel. It’s Booster’s struggles for acceptance and getting what few good relationships he can that make him memorable.

Plastic Man Checklist

Plastic Man is one of those characters whose sense of humor belies the creative angles. With powers that allow him to perform cartoony feats, Eel O’Brian is an artistically versatile character.

Swamp Thing Checklist

Swamp Thing is without a doubt a masterpiece made famous by Alan Moore and successors like Scott Snyder. However, a small number of stories bring some developments that not many people take advantage of.

Shade The Changing “X” Checklist

Shade lives up to their name of “The Changing X” as they never appear as the same person twice. The entire characters’ arc is about introspection and debunking hoaxes. So influential that it takes a very surreal look at how people and societies function.

Underrated DC Comics: Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad may be a name everyone is familiar with from live-action movies and video games; but until Tom Taylor the only good depiction was John Ostrander’s original take. Afterwards just a few small issues and arcs manage to strike the right chords of absurd supervillain interactivity.

Ambush Bug

Ambush Bug is is one of comics’ first characters with fourth wall awareness. Created by comedic writer Keith Giffen as an unimpressive Superman rogue, Irwin Schwab’s embrace of comics’ insanity is never a dull moment.

Manhunter Checklist

The Manhunters have a very unique history in DC. The originals are agents of a secret society in dedication to bringing justice to criminals who escape the legal system. The name’s use in the Green Lantern lore however causes some confusion about the title bearer’s identities.

Freedom Fighters

The Freedom Fighters are Earth X (10)’s superheroes because the Justice League are Nazis.

Dial H

What has a dial and lets you turn into a hero? No, not Ben 10’s Omnitrix, I’m talking about Dial H. This magical item allows its users to become a random hero with the most bizarre powers and designs. With any luck and a little effort the user can turn their life around.

Underrated DC Comics: Wildstorm

Following DC acquiring the company, Wildstorm and its properties often get overlooked by the main DC line. Probably because it lost whatever direction it had.

Underrated DC Comics: Vertigo/Young Animal

Before Vertigo fully mixed with DC, it introduces a number of original IP stories. But for every Fables spin-off are series that people miss. Following one website’s example we will include some Young Animal series.

Underrated DC Comics: Milestone Media

The legacy of the late Dwayne McDuffie recently reopened the floodgates after years of company politics clashing. Aside from the likes of Static and Icon, there are a few titles that don’t get enough attention.

Underrated DC Comics: Hanna-Barbera

Owing to DC’s ownership by Warner Bros. Media, it’s not surprising that some of Hanna-Barbera’s properties show up. But when The Flintstones and Scooby-Doo take up most of the attention, who will remember the rest?

 

Exit mobile version