Shazam! Sorry I couldnโt resist. With the movie starring Zachary Levi and Asher Angel, itโs time to get electrifying. People are free to call the character Captain Marvel or Thunder. Personally I think Shazam sounds more fitting as it complements the fun loving aspects of a serious name. But thatโs not the real topic; Iโm here to ask the important question of whether Shazam and Billy Batson are the same.
Holey Moley! Shazam is a Scam!

Hold on donโt click off somewhere else yet. There are things you gotta understand about the mantle. In a few comics including Shazam! The Monster Society of Evil, โCaptain Marvelโ is not Billyโs alter-ego, but a separate entity. As the wizard explains, Captain Marvel is Billy Batsonโs best self and emotional guidance. But thatโs just one story and ideas from the old comics I hear you say. Well guess again! The Dark Knight Captain Marvel actually survives after Billy dies.

Still not convinced? Even in the old Young Justice comics, Billy becomes separate from his alter-ego. (The Young Justice TV Show actually embraces the potential plot there). Meanwhile in Flashpoint, Billy is not the only one who possesses the magical power of the Wizard; instead he shares his power with five other kids to become Captain Thunder. All of which were part of the canon. Which brings me the idea of what Shazam really is.
Shazam is The Wizardโs Persona
The wizard who gives Billy his powers is actually the first Shazam, harnessing his magic through fallen predecessors. The wizard claims that the mantle harnesses the power from gods that just happen to occupy the same domains. But this seems rather far-fetched, unless the wizard can change aspects of what the gods give. I mean the courage of Achilles; doesnโt he come with invulnerability?

Thatโs when it hit me, the wizardโs magic lightning doesnโt go to a successor, the wizard is the magic. Thatโs why the Wizard canโt leave the Rock of Eternity; after growing so old he canโt leave the spot. So heโs been looking for a new body to finally leave the chamber. Itโs also why when Billy fully embraces his role that the Wizard turns to dust; and why Billy can talk to the Wizardโs spirit. I wonder if the wizard hears the voices of his fallen friends. Even before the New 52, The Trials of Shazam makes Billy the new wizard of his base of the Rock of Eternity.
Hereโs Why

But if thatโs the case, what about Black Adam? Easy, the wizard didnโt give him the full power since Adam wasnโt ready yet. Probably a good thing that he didnโt. Obviously heโs looking for a body of someone who does good for goodness sake. Otherwise he would have to deal with the messes his host body leaves behind. Not to mention avoid the awkward teen years or roaring twenties; cause who wants to go through that again?

Okay but what about the rest of the Shazam family? They arenโt built to be hosts. Best guess, they are backups in case Billy doesnโt work out. Because why limit to just one body when anything can happen?
Long Term Plan
When Iโm saying it like this, it brings a whole lot of feelings into the mix. If I was MatPat, this would be the part that I would say something like this. Billy isnโt given a gift, heโs trading his life away for wish-fulfillment. All the while the Wizard will live off his accomplishments. But wait, thereโs more.
The Wizardโs made a lot of mistakes over the years; he probably wants to make amends. Unfortunately, he has to leave it to a kid going through his own problems. Billyโs a good kid but requires guidance; even the wisdom of King Solomon is no substitute. The Wizard and Billy give each other what they really need.
But rather than babysit Billy all of the time; the Wizard allows Billy to use the magic to grow. Billy not only has the ability to fulfill his juvenile wishes, but give hope to others. After losing his family he begins to gain one over the course of his adventures. From Mary, Uncle Dudley, Tawky Tawny, and many more Billy finds hope he thought he lost. In turn, after seeing how that hope can influence others; Billy becomes a hero who shares time with the Justice League.
By the time he inevitably dies, Billy will live a fulfilled life; and the Wizard can use the legacy of Shazam on his path for redemption. Or at least until the Darkseid War; the Wizard decides to drop his plans and actually empower Billy with gods. The Wizard himself is actually the god Mamaragan. Wait I thought the Wizard was Egyptian? And now he came back to life? Ughโฆ Iโll save those for another time.
Thanks for coming to the end; and as always remember to look between the panels.
Discover more from Gutternaut
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.